We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation. Learn more. Shopping Food and Kitchen Reviews Cooking Tool Reviews The 8 Best Cookie Scoops of 2024 Make uniform and consistent cookies with these cookie scoops. By Michelle Love Michelle Love Michelle has spent the past 9 years working as a journalist. She has worked for publications that span from news organizations to magazines. She most recently worked for Shelby County Newspapers as a staff writer and currently does freelance for a variety of publications. Learn about BHG's Editorial Process Published on January 2, 2024 In This Article Expand Jump to a Section Our top picks Reviews The Bottom Line What to Know Before Shopping Your Questions, Answered Who We Are Better Homes & Gardens / David Hattan Everyone loves a good cookie, and baking cookies is arguably just as fun as eating them. Whether you’re a pastry chef, an at-home chef, or just wanting to enjoy some quality time with the family, there’s something so rewarding about making your own cookies. Using a cookie scoop is an essential part of the cookie baking experience. Cookie scoops ensure that the cookies will be a uniform size with every scoop. Catherine McCord, head recipe developer of Weelicious.com and author of Meal Prep Magic, says using a cookie scoop is beneficial for several reasons. “Cookie scoops ensure that the cookie dough will be a consistent size with each cookie, which means the cookies will bake evenly, so everything cooks at the same rate and time,” she says. “This is part of the reason that bakery cookies always look so even and perfect when you buy them.” We researched the best cookie scoops and considered factors like size, material, care, and usability. We also kept in mind the advice from our experts to find the best options. Our Top Picks Best Overall: Saebye Cookie Scoop at Amazon ($10) Jump to Review Best Budget: The Pioneer Woman Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop and Dropper at Walmart ($7) Jump to Review Best Splurge: King Arthur Baking Company Tablespoon Cookie Scoop at Kingarthurbaking.com (See Price) Jump to Review Best Professional: Vollrath Jacob's Pride Yellow Thumb Press Disher at Webstaurantstore.com (See Price) Jump to Review Best Small: OXO Small Cookie Scoop at Amazon ($16) Jump to Review Best Large: Junadael Cookie Dough Scoop at Amazon ($10) Jump to Review Best Set: Homure H Cookie Scoop Set at Amazon ($20) Jump to Review Best Colors: Gorilla Grip Stainless Steel Multipurpose Scoop at Amazon ($11) Jump to Review Best Overall Saebye Cookie Scoop Amazon View On Amazon $10 Why You Should Get It This cookie scoop is made from 18/8 stainless steel so it’s durable enough to last through wear-and-tear and is easy to clean. Keep in Mind Harsh detergents should be avoided when washing. The Saebye Cookie Scoop is everything a cookie scoop should be. It’s easy to use, efficient, and makes beautiful uniform cookies. This scoop holds 2.4 tablespoons of dough, which yields a cookie 3 inches in diameter. The trigger handle is designed for easy dough release—just push the lever with your thumb and the dough is gently released. This scoop is designed so that residual dough won’t get left behind in the scoop. The grooved purple handle adds a pop of color and is comfortable for most hand sizes. The scoop bowl is made from 18/8 stainless steel, which means it’s durable and easy to clean. The scoop is dishwasher safe even in restaurant-grade dishwashers, but you should use a gentle dishwasher detergent. Tyler Mosier, the head pastry chef at Foodbar in Birmingham, Alabama, says this is the scoop he uses to make cookies at home for his family and also making cookies at Foodbar. “This is the type of scoop my mom made cookies with when I was growing up,” he says. “It lasts forever and it always makes a good looking cookie.” Product Details: Size: 2.4 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Budget The Pioneer Woman Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop and Dropper Walmart View On Walmart $7 Why You Should Get It The scoop handle has a beautiful design from The Pioneer Woman’s Sweet Romance collection. Keep in Mind This scoop is recommended hand wash and dry only. For those looking for a scoop that’s a great bargain and also stylish, the Pioneer Woman Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop and Dropper is the best cookie scoop. This stainless steel scoop is designed to efficiently scoop and release cookie dough into a uniform shape. The thumb-trigger release releases the dough with an effortless click of the thumb, and the bowl holds 1.5 tablespoons of dough which makes 2.75-inch cookies. The handle is contoured for comfort, and is beautifully crafted with a floral pattern from The Pioneer Woman’s Sweet Romance collection. Overall, this scoop is reliable, stylish, and affordable. This would be a great gift for an at-home baker who enjoys making cookies for their kids or for the holidays. The one drawback is this scoop is meant for hand wash and dry only and is not dishwasher safe. Product Details: Size: 1.5 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Hand wash and dry only Best Splurge King Arthur Baking Company Tablespoon Cookie Scoop King Arthur Baking Company View On Kingarthurbaking.com Why You Should Get It This cookie scoop was built with the intention of heavy everyday use so it’s incredibly durable. Keep in Mind The dough tends to stick to the scoop so using a nonstick spray is recommended. For those who are willing to splurge on a high-quality cookie scoop, we love the King Arthur Baking Company Tablespoon Cookie Scoop. The bowl holds 1 tablespoon of cookie dough, which yields a 2.5-inch cookie. This scoop was designed with a squeeze handle that’s slim enough for all hand sizes, and it is designed to last for years even when used everyday in a commercial kitchen. Just a simple squeeze of the hand and dough is easily released onto the baking sheet. This handle is different from typically squeeze triggers in that there’s no connective spring in the middle, so there’s no chance of any parts slipping out of place and makes cleaning a breeze. Its stainless steel construction provides durability, and it comes with a colorful gear-triggered squeeze handle. While this scoop is consistent in its dough size, we recommend spraying the bowl with a nonstick baking spray to ensure the dough does not stick. The scoop is easy to clean and is dishwasher safe. It’s definitely worth the investment whether for professional chefs or at-home bakers. Product Details: Size: 1 tablespoon | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Professional Vollrath Jacob's Pride Yellow Thumb Press Disher Webstaurant Store View On Webstaurantstore.com Why You Should Get It This cookie scoop is antimicrobial as it was built to prevent bacteria from building up in the crevices. Keep in Mind The springs holding the thumb release in place may slip out of line occasionally. Vollrath is a major staple in the restaurant industry. The Vollrath company has been in operation since 1874 creating stainless steel products for commercial restaurants, and cookie scoops are one of the many things they’ve mastered. In my 13 years working in the restaurant industry, I’ve used many Vollrath products from their cookie scoops to their cookware, and they have always performed exceptionally. The Vollrath 47144 Jacob's Pride #20 Yellow Thumb Press Disher is a restaurant-quality product that creates beautiful and consistent cookies with an ideal shape and size. The bowl of the scoops holds 3.3 tablespoons of dough, which makes a 3.3-inch cookie. Its sturdy design is meant to last through the toughest wear-and-tear of restaurant life. The scoop is made from a high quality 18/8 stainless steel, which prevents the scoop from breaking down, even in a high volume environment like a bakery or restaurant. The gear-triggered thumb handle scoops out dough completely in uniform dough balls, and the yellow coated handle gives a pop of color. One of the scoop’s major features is it is antimicrobial, meaning it was built to prevent bacteria from building up in the crevices. It’s also a versatile scoop as it can even be used for other soft serve foods, like mashed potatoes. We also love that it’s dishwasher safe, so it can easily be cleaned. As someone who has worked with this type of scoop closely, Mosier says it should be noted that the springs holding the thumb release may slip out of place, but it can easily be popped back in. Product Details: Size: 3.3 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel scoop, coated handle | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Small OXO Small Cookie Scoop Amazon View On Amazon $16 Why You Should Get It This cookie scoop is heat-resistant. Keep in Mind This is not an ideal cookie scoop for making chocolate chip cookies. It’s much better suited for chipless cookies. The Oxo Good Grips Small Cookie Scoop is the best cookie scoop for making small cookies. Its simple yet ergonomic design comes with a spring-loaded squeeze handle and a stainless steel scoop that holds approximately 2 tablespoons of cookie dough which makes 2-inch cookies. The handle is a matte black and designed for quick and easy release. Just squeeze the handle and the cookie dough is placed on the cookie sheet with no leftover dough sticking to the bowl. The scoop is dishwasher safe and heat-resistant. The only downside is due to its size, the bowl scraper does not work well with chocolate chip cookie dough as the chunks can be too bulky for the trigger. This scoop works much better with chipless dough such as sugar cookies or snickerdoodle cookies. Product Details: Size: 2 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Large Junadael Cookie Dough Scoop Amazon View On Amazon $10 Why You Should Get It This scoop is versatile enough it can be used for cookie dough, ice cream, and even side dishes. Keep in Mind The handle is very slender for its size so holding it can seem awkward compared to a larger handle. If you love to make big cookies, the Junadael 5.5-Tablespoon Cookie Dough Scoop is the best cookie scoop. This scoop holds 5.5 tablespoons of dough to make uniform cookies close to 4 inches in diameter. This scoop is fantastic for making large cookies with the family whether enjoying with a tall glass of milk or to make ice cream sandwiches. With its gear-triggered thumb press, cookies are easily expelled from the cookie scoop. It’s dishwasher safe and built for professional or at-home use. It’s also versatile enough it can be used for other foods as well. The handle, however, is very slender for the scoop’s overall size so depending on hand size it could be awkward to hold. Product Details: Size: 5.5 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Set Homure H Cookie Scoop Set Amazon View On Amazon $20 Why You Should Get It This set includes three different cookie scoop sizes. Keep in Mind These scoops cannot be used on firm or hard dough. The Homure H Cookie Scoop Set comes with three scoops to make a variety of different sized cookies for all occasions. It provides three separate cookie scoops including a 1-tablespoon scoop, a 2-tablespoon scoop, and a 3-tablespoon scoop. The squeeze handle makes them easy to use, and the nonslip grip of the handle provides comfort and security even with the stickiest dough. The bowl is made from high quality 18/8 stainless steel that fights corrosion. Each scoop is efficient, practical, and comfortable to use. Due to the range in size, the set can be used for multiple cookie and baking options. All included cookie scoops are dishwasher safe. It is advised to not use these scoops on firm dough as it can damage the scraper. Product Details: Size: 1 tablespoon, 2 tablespoons, and 3 tablespoons | Material: Stainless steel | Care: Dishwasher safe Best Colors Gorilla Grip Stainless Steel Multipurpose Scoop Amazon View On Amazon $11 View On Gorillagrip.com Why You Should Get It This stainless steel cookie scoop comes in eight different color options to fit any aesthetic. Keep in Mind The spring mechanism between the two handles can get dough trapped inside easily. For those looking to add a splash of color to their kitchen, this is the best cookie scoop for you. Its sleek stainless steel bowl holds approximately 1 tablespoon of dough, and the handle is made from a comfortable rubber that comes in eight different color options. This scoop will make a fantastic addition to any kitchen collection. It’s super durable, and it also comes in a variety of different sizes that can be used for cookies, cupcake batter, or even ice cream. The scoop bowl is stainless steel and the handle is a durable, soft-touch rubber, but all components are dishwasher safe. Each scoop provides consistent and uniform balls of dough in their respective sizes. The squeeze handle scoops the dough out of the bowl thoroughly and makes it easy and convenient to use. Our only complaint is the gear triggers in between the springs can get dough trapped inside easily so it’s important to pay attention to that area. Product Details: Size: 1 tablespoon | Material: Stainless steel scoop with a coated rubber handle | Care: Dishwasher safe The Bottom Line We chose the Saebye Cookie Scoop as our best overall cookie scoop because of its durability and efficiency. We also appreciate that despite its high quality, it’s available at an affordable price point. What to Know About Cookie Scoops Before Shopping Size Cookie scoops come in a variety of different sizes. If you want smaller cookies, look for a cookie scoop with a capacity of 1 or 2 tablespoons, like the Oxo Good Grips Small Cookie Scoop. For larger cookies, use a scoop that can hold several tablespoons, such as the Junadael 5.5-Tablespoon Cookie Dough Scoop. McCord says thanks to cookie scoop sets, home chefs are able to have a variety of different sizes in one package. “If you have the space, keep a three-piece scoop set on hand,” she says. “1 tablespoon, 2 tablespoons, and a quarter cup are my go-to for scooping meatballs, ice cream, cookie dough, balls, and more.” Material “Stainless steel is the way to go because it’s durable and easy to clean,” Mosier says. Most of the cookie scoops on our list are made from 18/8 stainless steel, a very high quality steel that fights corrosion and is dishwasher safe. Handles, however, are a different story. The handle of a cookie scoop can range from the same stainless steel to a matte rubber handle or a plastic coated handle. When it comes to the handle material, coated plastic is usually the best because it’s easier to handle and is easy to clean. Care Most cookie scoops today are dishwasher safe, which saves all chefs time and patience. However, there are some scoops that have specific instructions for cleaning. For example the Saebye Cookie Scoop is dishwasher safe, but it should avoid harsh detergents as it can break down the integrity of the scoop. The Pioneer Woman Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop and Dropper should be hand washed with a mild dish soap. When in doubt, pay close attention to the care instructions of the cookie scoop because taking proper care can ensure a longer lifespan. Usability If you’re someone who will be making cookies on a regular basis, it’s essential to find a cookie scoop that’s easy and comfortable to use. Cookie scoops usually come with two handle options: a hand-squeeze method where you squeeze the two handles together to work the scoop, or a gear-trigger thumb press which is operated by springs that activate when the trigger is pressed with the thumb. Mosier says while the hand-squeeze scoops work fine, he personally prefers a gear-trigger thumb press. “It’s just easier to use and requires almost no effort,” he said. “It’s what I grew up with and it saves any extra steps. I also like the thumb press because those are easier to clean.” Your Questions, Answered How much are cookie scoops? Cookie scoops range in pricing depending on branding and sizes. The larger cookie scoops tend to push closer to the $20 range like the Tablespoon Cookie Scoop by King Arthur Baking Company which is $25. Smaller cookie scoops can be as low as $10, like The Pioneer Woman Stainless Steel Cookie Scoop and Dropper. How do you keep dough from getting stuck in a cookie scoop? There are two ways to prevent cookie dough from sticking to a cookie scoop. McCord says she highly recommends spraying the cookie scoops with nonstick spray before scooping dough. Mosier says he also highly recommends using hot water as a nonstick method. Simply run hot water over the scoop or stick the scoop in a cup with hot water to heat the steel before scooping. This will make scooping harder doughs much easier and will allow the scoop to collect dough more efficiently, and it will be easier to release the dough onto a cookie sheet. Who We Are Michelle Love is a freelance commerce writer for Better Homes & Gardens. She has extensive experience as a freelance writer and has also worked in the restaurant, bar, and catering industry for the past 13 years. To find out more about cookie scoops, she spoke with Catherine McCord, who is the head writer and recipe developer for Weelicious.com and is the author of Meal Prep Magic. Tyler Mosier is the head pastry chef at Foodbar in Birmingham, Alabama. Was this page helpful? Thanks for your feedback! Tell us why! Other Submit